Jesus as poor (illiterate) Galilean peasant

Aslan repeatedly calls Jesus a poor Galilean peasant in what clearly is a condescending tone. He argues that Jesus was illiterate (pp. 34-36). Craig Evans [“Jewish Scripture and the Literacy of Jesus,” From Biblical Criticism to Biblical Faith, Mercer University Press, 2007, pp. 46-54] argues persuasively for the literacy of Jesus. He points out the rhetorical device commonly used by Jesus: What is in scriptures, how do you read them? This would be a curious device for an illiterate to use. Perhaps Aslan overlooks this because he largely ignores the role of Jesus as teacher.
[As for dismissing him as a poor peasant, Mullah Omar was born of landless peasants from the Urozgan province of Afghanistan. Yet by the time he was in his mid- to late 30’s he was de facto head of the Afghan state. He could speak Arabic and had gotten enough education to become a mullah in a village near Kandahar. (The Wikipedia article on Mullah Omar cites Lawrence Wright’s The Looming Tower, 2006 and various Reuters articles for this information.) Sometimes we dismiss poor peasants at our peril.]

Aslan may doubt the authenticity of passages that portray Jesus as a rabbi. This is because of a series of cumulative assumptions he makes. Jesus is from a very small town–he puts it at 100 families. Therefore Aslan assumes that it had “no roads, no public buildings. There is no synagogue” p. 25.  Yet there has been little archeological work in Nazareth (“Is Jesus’ Hometown (Nazareth) a Myth?” Joseph M. Holden Ph.D.). So that it had no synagogue is speculation. Aslan further speculates that if it had no synagogue, Jesus had no formal education and further speculates that he is therefore illiterate. Therefore he uses a series of cumulative assumptions to overrule actual evidence. If Jesus was illiterate, the rabbis would not have engaged him in learned dialogue.

On the other hand, Aslan admits that Jesus probably spent a great part of his carpenter career rebuilding the cosmopolitan city of Sepphoris, an hour’s walk from Nazareth. (This makes Aslan’s portrayal of Jesus as a peasant rather than a carpenter puzzling at best.) Is it more speculative to think that an extremely devout Joseph might have dropped Jesus off at a rabbinical school in Sepphoris and then picked him up after work, at least until his eldest son had proper training in the Law? This speculation has the added value of explaining the evidence of Jesus discussing the Law with the rabbis.

6 thoughts on “Jesus as poor (illiterate) Galilean peasant”

  1. Hey there! I’m at work surfing around your blog from my new iphone 3gs! Just wanted to say I love reading your blog and look forward to all your posts! Carry on the fantastic work!

  2. When I originally commented I clicked the “Notify me when new comments are added” checkbox and now each time a comment is added
    I get several emails with the same comment. Is there any way you can remove me from that service?

    Here is my website; Social Security — Disability
    Lawyer – FindLaw Lawyers Directory (Shawn)

    1. I have been busy completing my book and now am getting back to my blogsite. I will mark these ads as spam, and hopefully neither of us will see them in the future.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *